Notice: On April 23, 2014, Statalist moved from an email list to a forum, based at statalist.org.
[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
RE: st: r(610)
Nick Cox <email@example.com>
RE: st: r(610)
Tue, 25 Jan 2011 19:51:16 +0000
Very good point.
Schaffer, Mark E
The most important reason imho isn't in Nick's list: precision in
-outsheet- is determined by display format (!), and if you don't realise
this, the consequences are nasty. I was bitten by this recently:
> Using -saveold- is indeed generally preferable to exporting the data
> as a text file for precisely the reasons you identified, the likely
> loss of e.g. variable labels, display formats, characteristics
> (including notes).
> On Tue, Jan 25, 2011 at 3:56 PM, POPE, REBECCA <RPOPE@uams.edu> wrote:
> > I saw Nick's post mentioning both solutions, as well as
> Aggie's follow-up question about insheeting. However, I
> didn't see a post noting the virtues of one approach over the
> other, which seemed relevant. If Nick already posted that, it
> didn't arrive on my end & I apologize to the list for being
> duplicative. I'll try to catch it in the archives later.
> > If you were referring only to Nick's post about potential
> solutions and nothing was posted about why Aggie might want
> to ask her friend to use -saveold- instead of the
> -outsheet/insheet-, I would truly appreciate feedback on my
> view of _why_ it would be preferable for Aggie to ask her
> friend to use -saveold-. I ask this as much for my
> edification as a Stata user (since I frequently use
> -saveold-) as for Aggie's information.
> > Here is the text from my original post:
> > "I'm away from my computer right now so if someone else
> could confirm that would be great, but I think that would
> preserve any formatting, labels, notes, etc that Aggie's
> friend had applied to the data. That would save Aggie
> duplicating any pre-analysis prep work."
> > p.s. I read the help guide when I got back to my office and
> it only explicitly mentions labels. The woman I normally send
> the data sets to isn't in yet, so I can't confirm formats and
> notes myself as a benefit of -saveold- over -outsheet/insheet-.
* For searches and help try: