Notice: On March 31, it was **announced** that Statalist is moving from an email list to a **forum**. The old list will shut down at the end of May, and its replacement, **statalist.org** is already up and running.

[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

From |
Tom <tommedema@gmail.com> |

To |
statalist@hsphsun2.harvard.edu |

Subject |
Re: st: xtlogit: panel data transformation's recast to double makes model incomputable |

Date |
Wed, 3 Apr 2013 16:33:22 +0200 |

Hi Jay, Just to be clear -- I am also "on Nick's side". Anyway I don't want to be talking about sides, somehow that's somewhat associated with a battle and that is absolutely unrelated to this fruitful discussion. I want to stress that I did start with theory, and that it made me choose a fixed effects logistic regression. I am not somehow "choosing the model that gives me an answer". For example, I used - clogit, group()- but that is identical to -xtlogit, fe- so there is no change there. Moreover, I used -logit- but only to verify if this problem was related to panel data or not. For your information, I already started over. Anyway, I think I may have a very important pointer that could help in finding the cause of this issue: when I run -ladder close- it returns absolutely nothing, i.e.: ladder close Transformation formula chi2(2) P(chi2) ------------------------------------------------------------------ cubic close^3 . . square close^2 . . identity close . . square root sqrt(close) . . log log(close) . . 1/(square root) 1/sqrt(close) . . inverse 1/close . . 1/square 1/(close^2) . . 1/cubic 1/(close^3) . . I believe this is very much related to the problems I am having with this variable, close. If I can determine why ladder refuses to give me any transformations, then I may be able to figure out what is the source of this issue. I am not just trying to get an answer, I am interested in why ladder is not returning any transformations because this may give me information on the root cause of the problem. Thanks again. Tom On Wed, Apr 3, 2013 at 2:13 PM, JVerkuilen (Gmail) <jvverkuilen@gmail.com> wrote: > On Wed, Apr 3, 2013 at 7:54 AM, Tom <tommedema@gmail.com> wrote: >> I understand what you mean. Note that I did not use any of these other >> models until unexpected computational problems appeared. > > This is crazily simple but try rescaling the relevant price data. I > forget what the scale of them is, but try dividing them by, say, 1000. > The QR decomposition which is used computationally effectively does > this, but your horribly skewed and massively differently scaled data > may well be overwhelming even it. > > That said, I'm with Nick. This problem needs a major rethink. There > are simply too many levers being pulled right now to get a believable > answer. Even if a model converges it is still got the attached funk of > all the troubleshooting and tricks you needed to do to make things > work. > > In order: > > -Regenerate the data file "clean". Make sure all variables are scaled > appropriately and candidate transformations are chosen. (e.g., with > price data, log transform). This rules out mistakes or problems with > the datafile. > -Then lay out the model assumptions and framework. > -Then fit candidate models in a predictable sequence. > > You may well have done a lot of this, but going back to square one and > checking in sequence will help nail down what the problem is. You may > well end up back where you started, but the effort will not be wasted. > * > * For searches and help try: > * http://www.stata.com/help.cgi?search > * http://www.stata.com/support/faqs/resources/statalist-faq/ > * http://www.ats.ucla.edu/stat/stata/ * * For searches and help try: * http://www.stata.com/help.cgi?search * http://www.stata.com/support/faqs/resources/statalist-faq/ * http://www.ats.ucla.edu/stat/stata/

**Follow-Ups**:**Re: st: xtlogit: panel data transformation's recast to double makes model incomputable***From:*Nick Cox <njcoxstata@gmail.com>

**References**:**st: xtlogit: panel data transformation's recast to double makes model incomputable***From:*Tom <tommedema@gmail.com>

**Re: st: xtlogit: panel data transformation's recast to double makes model incomputable***From:*Maarten Buis <maartenlbuis@gmail.com>

**Re: st: xtlogit: panel data transformation's recast to double makes model incomputable***From:*Tom <tommedema@gmail.com>

**Re: st: xtlogit: panel data transformation's recast to double makes model incomputable***From:*"JVerkuilen (Gmail)" <jvverkuilen@gmail.com>

**AW: st: xtlogit: panel data transformation's recast to double makes model incomputable***From:*"Klaus Pforr" <kpforr@googlemail.com>

**Re: st: xtlogit: panel data transformation's recast to double makes model incomputable***From:*Tom <tommedema@gmail.com>

**Re: st: xtlogit: panel data transformation's recast to double makes model incomputable***From:*"JVerkuilen (Gmail)" <jvverkuilen@gmail.com>

**Re: st: xtlogit: panel data transformation's recast to double makes model incomputable***From:*Tom <tommedema@gmail.com>

**Re: st: xtlogit: panel data transformation's recast to double makes model incomputable***From:*"JVerkuilen (Gmail)" <jvverkuilen@gmail.com>

**Re: st: xtlogit: panel data transformation's recast to double makes model incomputable***From:*Tom <tommedema@gmail.com>

**Re: st: xtlogit: panel data transformation's recast to double makes model incomputable***From:*"JVerkuilen (Gmail)" <jvverkuilen@gmail.com>

**Re: st: xtlogit: panel data transformation's recast to double makes model incomputable***From:*Nick Cox <njcoxstata@gmail.com>

**Re: st: xtlogit: panel data transformation's recast to double makes model incomputable***From:*Tom <tommedema@gmail.com>

**Re: st: xtlogit: panel data transformation's recast to double makes model incomputable***From:*Nick Cox <njcoxstata@gmail.com>

**Re: st: xtlogit: panel data transformation's recast to double makes model incomputable***From:*Tom <tommedema@gmail.com>

**Re: st: xtlogit: panel data transformation's recast to double makes model incomputable***From:*Nick Cox <njcoxstata@gmail.com>

**Re: st: xtlogit: panel data transformation's recast to double makes model incomputable***From:*Tom <tommedema@gmail.com>

**Re: st: xtlogit: panel data transformation's recast to double makes model incomputable***From:*"JVerkuilen (Gmail)" <jvverkuilen@gmail.com>

- Prev by Date:
**Re: st: where's the code for -total- ?** - Next by Date:
**Re: st: xtlogit: panel data transformation's recast to double makes model incomputable** - Previous by thread:
**Re: st: xtlogit: panel data transformation's recast to double makes model incomputable** - Next by thread:
**Re: st: xtlogit: panel data transformation's recast to double makes model incomputable** - Index(es):