Notice: On April 23, 2014, Statalist moved from an email list to a forum, based at statalist.org.

# st: RE: Noconst in cointegration relationship in VECM

 From Nick Cox <[email protected]> To "'[email protected]'" <[email protected]> Subject st: RE: Noconst in cointegration relationship in VECM Date Thu, 28 Apr 2011 14:49:51 +0100

```I don't know how to do what you want, but I don't see that it makes much sense anyway.

If I am misunderstanding, naturally feel free to correct me, but this is my analysis.
I am regarding -vec- as just a fancy regression, but that could be very wrong.

The names of your variables indicate that they are all natural logs of something else.

If you want to force a relationship through the origin, that implies, as I understand it, forcing it through lnprice = lnrent = lnAM = 0 which in turn implies that there is some white magic about the point with three coordinates

Price = 1 (in whatever units price is measured)

Rent = 1 (ditto)

AM = 1 (ditto)

-- which seems an almighty strong assumption, and privileges the units of measuring you are using, which normally is just a matter of convention.

Otherwise put, there can be some definite rationale about forcing through an origin (0, 0) which is, in original coordinates, a limiting case which should be approached, e.g. tiny animals can be expected to converge on some point like

Weight = 0, length = 0

But why should this be true on logarithmic scales?

Nick
[email protected]

I am trying to have no constant in the cointegration vector in the VEC model.

I know how to have constraints on the variables, but the constant does
not work in the same way. For example if I restrict (i.e.) the
variable lnrent:

constraint define 1 [_ce1]lnrent=1

vec lnprice lnrent lnAM, rank(1) lags(2) trend(constant) bconstraints(1)

It works fine.

Then I am thinking that it should only be to restrict the constant in
the same way:

constraint define 1 [_ce1]_cons=0

vec lnprice lnrent lnAM, rank(1) lags(2) trend(constant) bconstraints(1)

But this do not work.