# st: Correlation estimates near boundary value in asmprobit

 From "Groeneveld, Rolf" To Subject st: Correlation estimates near boundary value in asmprobit Date Sun, 18 May 2008 13:08:41 +0200

```When using asmprobit to analyse the data of a stated preference survey I'm getting estimations of the correlation coefficient very close to 1 or -1. Different covariance matrices and different base and scale variables all give an estimate very close to its boundary. What could cause this result? Is it a problem for my estimates? What can I do about it?

Here is example of the results I get (the survey has three alternatives in each question):

. asmprobit choice stock benth layov costs, case(obs) alternatives(_altnum) base(1) scale(2)

Alternative-specific multinomial probit        Number of obs      =      22464
Case variable: obs                             Number of cases    =       7488

Alternative variable: _altnum                  Alts per case: min =          3
avg =        3.0
max =          3
Integration sequence:      Hammersley
Integration points:               150             Wald chi2(4)    =     423.47
Log simulated-likelihood = -6053.3294             Prob > chi2     =     0.0000

------------------------------------------------------------------------------
choice |      Coef.   Std. Err.      z    P>|z|     [95% Conf. Interval]
-------------+----------------------------------------------------------------
_altnum      |
stock |   .1626189   .0162338    10.02   0.000     .1308011    .1944366
benth |   .2973948   .0547786     5.43   0.000     .1900307     .404759
layov |   .2402472   .0268319     8.95   0.000     .1876577    .2928367
costs |  -.0138585   .0018745    -7.39   0.000    -.0175325   -.0101846
-------------+----------------------------------------------------------------
_alt_1       |  (base alternative)
-------------+----------------------------------------------------------------
_alt_2       |
_cons |   .9968469   .1406466     7.09   0.000     .7211846    1.272509
-------------+----------------------------------------------------------------
_alt_3       |
_cons |   1.060629   .1027839    10.32   0.000     .8591764    1.262082
-------------+----------------------------------------------------------------
/lnl2_2 |  -2.930848   3.865245    -0.76   0.448    -10.50659    4.644894
-------------+----------------------------------------------------------------
/l2_1 |   .9807269   .0573761    17.09   0.000     .8682719    1.093182
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
(_altnum=1 is the alternative normalizing location)
(_altnum=2 is the alternative normalizing scale)

. estat corr

+-------------------------------+
|              | _alt_2  _alt_3 |
|--------------+----------------|
|       _alt_2 |  1.000         |
|       _alt_3 |  0.999   1.000 |
+-------------------------------+
Note: correlations are for alternatives differenced with _alt_1

Best regards,

Rolf A. Groeneveld
Wageningen University
Environmental Economics and Natural Resources Group
Hollandseweg 1
NL-6706 KN  Wageningen
+31 317 482009

```

<<winmail.dat>>