[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date index][Thread index]
Re: st: comparison of diagnostic procedures
htzvara (?) wrote:
>>> i have one variable which represents if the patient has the disease
>>> 1)--and this is standard.
>>> Additionally i have 12 more variables which represents the outcome of 12
>>> different diagnostic procedures (coding: 0-1 for all of them).I want
>>> to find
>>> which is the best diagnostic procedure. I calculate the sensitivity and
>>> specificity and their confidence intervals for each of them. If the
>>> interval for the sensitivity of one diagnostic procedure do not
>>> overlap the
>>> confidence interval for the Se of another diagnostic procedure then the
>>> difference is significant.
>>> Is there any test to perform and give p_value? Is there a need to make a
>>> correction for multiple comparisons.?
and Michael P. Mueller replied:
You might want to take a look at this book: Pepe, M.S. (2003).
Statistical Evaluation of Medical Tests for Classification and
Prediction. Dr. Pepe has Stata programs on her webpage you can download.
To follow-up on Michael's suggestions with a link and a pointer to specific
programs that might be useful -
Hope this helps,
The webpage for Margaret's book can be found at:
The specific programs that might be helpful for evaluating binary screening
tests are -binscrn1-, -binscrn2-, and -binscrn3-. The first of these provides
estimates and CI's (Wilson, Clopper-Pearson, and logit-based) for true and false
positive fractions (i.e. sensitivity and 1-specificity), positive and negative
predictive values (assuming cohort data), and Diagnostic likelihood ratios. The
2nd and 3rd programs compare these measures for 2 screening tests, given
unpaired and paired data, respectively.
Have been meaning to submit these as a package to SSC.
* For searches and help try: