[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date index][Thread index]
Re: st: general statistical reasoning question in biomedical statistics(no Stata content)
A very good point. Thank you for reminding me.
> Let me be picky with just one point you make because I see it
> repeated too often, and that is the issue that, "And for every 20
> baseline variables compared, you'd *expect* about 1 of those baseline
> variables to have a P of < 0.05"
> This is a misquote of a mathematical tautology that says that 5% of
> all tests (1 in 20) will fall into the 5% region. The proper quote
> is that this refers to *independent* tests. This oversight is
> especially important here because if ever one should question the
> independence assumption it is in this situation. When we are looking
> at a number of baseline characteristrics on the patients, it is
> probably more than likely that there is some dependence amongst them.
> For example, if the two arms are not balanced with respect to height
> with one arm getting the shorter patients, then more than likely
> that arm will have the lighter patients too.
> So when we do a number of related tests, we may get more or less
> than 5% significant due to chance. It all depends on the
> structure of the dependency, a point that should be made to students.
* For searches and help try: